Hollywood & Hallandale Beach Pizza Comparison
Mad Pizza vs El Tamarindo Coal Fired Pizza
A 4.9-star family pizzeria with four generations of Sicilian tradition versus a 4.3-star coal-fired spot in Hallandale Beach. Discover why more locals are choosing Mad Pizza.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Coal-fired ovens create great heat, but it takes more than an oven to make great pizza. It takes generations of perfected recipes and fresh daily ingredients.
Why Choose Mad Pizza Over El Tamarindo?
El Tamarindo serves solid coal-fired pizza, but Mad Pizza brings a level of heritage, freshness, and community commitment that is hard to beat.
The Ratings Don't Lie
Mad Pizza's 4.9-star rating from 150+ Google reviews is the highest in the Hollywood area. El Tamarindo sits at 4.3 stars. When that many customers consistently choose Mad Pizza, the quality speaks for itself.
Sauce Worth Crossing Town For
Mad Pizza's Sicilian sauce recipe has been handed down through four generations — from a great-grandmother's kitchen in Sicily to Hollywood, FL. This depth of flavor is the kind of thing you simply cannot replicate with a standard house sauce.
Fresh Mozzarella, Hand-Shredded Daily
At Mad Pizza, the mozzarella is hand-shredded every morning. This creates a superior melt and richer taste compared to pre-shredded, pre-packaged cheese that many pizzerias — including coal-fired ones — use for convenience.
Giving Back to Those Who Served
Mad Pizza proudly partners with LEGION to support local veterans. Founded in 2024 by brothers Mat and Dustin, community service is baked into their mission. Your pizza purchase directly supports those who have served our country.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Mad Pizza better than El Tamarindo Coal Fired Pizza near Hollywood FL?
Mad Pizza holds a 4.9-star Google rating with over 150 reviews, compared to El Tamarindo's 4.3 stars. While El Tamarindo offers coal-fired pizza in Hallandale Beach, Mad Pizza delivers a unique Chicago thin-crust experience with hand-shredded mozzarella and a 4-generation Sicilian sauce recipe — all made fresh daily at 211 N 21st Ave, Hollywood, FL.
What is the difference between Mad Pizza and El Tamarindo's coal-fired pizza?
El Tamarindo uses a coal-fired oven to produce charred, high-heat pizzas. Mad Pizza takes a different approach with authentic Chicago thin-crust — a perfectly crispy base paired with hand-shredded mozzarella and a Sicilian sauce recipe passed down through four generations. Both styles have their fans, but Mad Pizza's higher rating speaks for itself.
Can Mad Pizza deliver to Hallandale Beach where El Tamarindo is located?
Yes, Mad Pizza delivers throughout Hollywood, FL and neighboring areas including Hallandale Beach, Dania Beach, and parts of Fort Lauderdale. You can order online or call (754) 275-8466. Every order supports veterans through Mad Pizza's LEGION partnership.
Four Generations of Flavor. One Order Away.
Order from Hollywood's top-rated pizzeria and find out why over 150 customers gave us a near-perfect score.