Hollywood, FL Pizza Comparison
Mad Pizza vs Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza in Hollywood, FL
Two quality options — but only one is a true local, family-owned pizzeria with Sicilian heritage and a 4.9-star rating.
How They Stack Up
Anthony's Coal Fired is a well-known regional chain with 60+ locations. Mad Pizza is a single-location family pizzeria with roots in Sicilian tradition. Here's how they compare.
Why Choose Mad Pizza Over Anthony's Coal Fired?
Anthony's makes solid pizza — but when it comes to local roots, family heritage, and community impact, Mad Pizza stands alone in Hollywood, FL.
True Local vs Regional Chain
Anthony's operates 60+ locations across Florida, the Northeast, and other states. They're a multi-state restaurant group, not a local business. Mad Pizza has one location — right here at 211 N 21st Ave in Hollywood — owned by brothers who are part of this community.
Four Generations of Sicilian Tradition
Mad Pizza's sauce recipe has been in the family for four generations, originating in Sicily. Anthony's certainly makes good food, but their recipes are designed for chain-wide replication across dozens of locations. There's a difference between a restaurant group recipe and a family heirloom.
Chicago Thin-Crust Craftsmanship
Anthony's specializes in coal-fired, well-done crust — a particular style you can find at any of their 60+ locations. Mad Pizza brings authentic Chicago thin-crust technique to Hollywood, FL — a style that's genuinely rare in South Florida and impossible to find at any chain.
Veterans First
Mad Pizza's LEGION partnership represents a real commitment to supporting military veterans in the Hollywood, FL community. It's a personal mission for founders Mat and Dustin, not a corporate philanthropy initiative. Your pizza order directly supports those who served.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Mad Pizza better than Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza in Hollywood FL?
Both are quality options in Hollywood, FL, but Mad Pizza leads with a 4.9-star Google rating versus Anthony's 4.3 stars. The key difference is ownership: Mad Pizza is a true family-owned local business founded by brothers Mat and Dustin with 4-generation Sicilian recipes. Anthony's is a regional chain with over 60 locations across multiple states, owned by a restaurant group.
How does Mad Pizza's Chicago thin-crust compare to Anthony's coal-fired pizza?
These are two distinct pizza styles. Anthony's specializes in coal-fired pizza with a charred, well-done crust. Mad Pizza offers authentic Chicago thin-crust — a razor-thin, crispy crust topped with hand-shredded mozzarella and 4-generation Sicilian sauce. If you want unique, heritage-driven pizza in Hollywood, FL, Mad Pizza offers something you truly cannot get anywhere else.
Why choose a single-location pizzeria like Mad Pizza over a regional chain like Anthony's?
When you order from Mad Pizza, you're supporting a true Hollywood, FL family business. Brothers Mat and Dustin are personally invested in every pizza that leaves their kitchen at 211 N 21st Ave. Anthony's operates 60+ locations — at that scale, consistency comes from systems, not personal attention. Mad Pizza also supports veterans through their LEGION partnership.
Does Mad Pizza offer a different experience than Anthony's Coal Fired?
Yes. Anthony's is a full-service sit-down chain restaurant with a broader menu and bar program. Mad Pizza focuses specifically on crafting exceptional pizza using family Sicilian recipes, hand-shredded mozzarella, and Chicago thin-crust technique. It's a more personal, community-focused experience with delivery and pickup options. Call (754) 275-8466 to order.
Taste Hollywood's Highest-Rated Pizza
4.9 stars. Four generations of Sicilian recipes. Authentic Chicago thin-crust. There's nothing else like it in South Florida.